The key statistic the publication relied on was “anonymous information about every active
Posted: Tue Jan 21, 2025 4:32 am
New York City user as of November 17, 2015,” and more specifically — countering concerns that the service was being overrun by agents renting out multiple units, using the precious aggregator to ensnare European tourists for profit instead of citizens who needed a place to live — 95% of owners who rent out entire homes only have one unit. That figure is crucial to supporting a story that Airbnb has been pushing harder and harder over the past year: that it is at the forefront of “the further evolution of capitalism” that will save the working and middle classes from being displaced by gentrification. And this story matters more in New York than in most other markets, because the majority of Airbnb’s entire rentals — about 57 percent of all listings in New York City, according to Inside Airbnb — are in direct violation of the state’s existing short-term rental law. ( You can read the discussion here .) So this story, which hinges heavily on those numbers, is essentially the service’s plan to legitimize itself in a city where it has to navigate a hostile regulatory environment.
Source
Source
But if Cox and Slee’s numbers are correct — and they’ve collected a ton of data and ukraine mobile phone numbers database trends over the past couple of years — those numbers could be inflated. Cox, who runs Inside Airbnb, a site that collects and analyzes Airbnb listings, said that as of November 1, he and Tom Slee had identified 3,331 listings owned by owners with two or more units. Three weeks later, 1,438 of them had disappeared. The normal turnover rate for such listings is about 200 a month, Cox says, “so we suspect that there are about 1,000 to 1,200 listings that are not consistent with the trend that we’ve seen.” He continues: “There was no significant increase in listings before November, so it’s very unlikely that 1,000 of them just disappeared, given that the rate has been fairly consistent all year.” Airbnb, which portrayed the data as “typical,” did not comment on the purge immediately before the release and even said there was no particular pressure to do so, Cox says. So where did all those apartments go?
(Since the story went live, an Airbnb spokesperson sent out the following statement: “Our community in NYC has evolved to the point where 94% of hosts only have one listing and where illegal hotels are not listed, so to have officials who previously called for a crackdown on these brokers now want to fine middle-class families $50,000 is like telling people to walk on water and then fining them for ‘not swimming.’” The company also provided a single chart showing that 95% had only one listing as of November 17, and that number had dropped by 1 percent as of February 8, to 94%.)
Source
Source
But if Cox and Slee’s numbers are correct — and they’ve collected a ton of data and ukraine mobile phone numbers database trends over the past couple of years — those numbers could be inflated. Cox, who runs Inside Airbnb, a site that collects and analyzes Airbnb listings, said that as of November 1, he and Tom Slee had identified 3,331 listings owned by owners with two or more units. Three weeks later, 1,438 of them had disappeared. The normal turnover rate for such listings is about 200 a month, Cox says, “so we suspect that there are about 1,000 to 1,200 listings that are not consistent with the trend that we’ve seen.” He continues: “There was no significant increase in listings before November, so it’s very unlikely that 1,000 of them just disappeared, given that the rate has been fairly consistent all year.” Airbnb, which portrayed the data as “typical,” did not comment on the purge immediately before the release and even said there was no particular pressure to do so, Cox says. So where did all those apartments go?
(Since the story went live, an Airbnb spokesperson sent out the following statement: “Our community in NYC has evolved to the point where 94% of hosts only have one listing and where illegal hotels are not listed, so to have officials who previously called for a crackdown on these brokers now want to fine middle-class families $50,000 is like telling people to walk on water and then fining them for ‘not swimming.’” The company also provided a single chart showing that 95% had only one listing as of November 17, and that number had dropped by 1 percent as of February 8, to 94%.)